Talent has always been one of the most reliable predictors of portfolio performance, across the mid‑market and upper mid‑market, private equity firms are reassessing how leadership is evaluated and hired because outcomes consistently show that capital alone does not create enterprise value. People do.

Portfolio performance depends on the operators responsible for delivering the investment thesis. When the CFO, COO, and CEO are misaligned with the growth plan, issues surface quickly: missed milestones, delayed operational improvements, and slowed commercial progress. When the right leaders are in place early, value creation moves faster.

‍

Leadership as a core investment lever

Firms that treat recruitment as a strategic investment outperform those that treat it as a transactional requirement. Experienced operators bring clarity, pace, and discipline. They know how to improve reporting accuracy, strengthen planning cycles, build reliable operating rhythms, and prepare the business for scale or exit.

Industry research shows that firms with structured value‑creation teams outperform those relying mainly on financial engineering (McKinsey, 2023). Strong leadership expands optionality. Investors increasingly ask not only “Who can run this business?” but “Who can improve margins, strengthen discipline, and accelerate value creation?”

‍

Why talent is often underweighted in due diligence

If leadership quality is so central, why is it still under‑evaluated during diligence?

Leadership is difficult to quantify

Financials, market size, and risk modelling are data‑driven. Leadership capability requires judgement, many deal teams lack the tools to evaluate executives rapidly and accurately.

Compressed deal timelines

Investors often spend only a few hours with management before signing, which is not enough to understand capability, alignment, or gaps.

Limited internal human‑capital expertise

Even well‑resourced firms do not always have dedicated talent specialists, without structured frameworks, leadership assessment becomes a post‑close task.

These gaps often show up during the first six to twelve months, when the company should be gaining traction.

‍

Risks created by weak or misaligned leadership

When leadership and the investment strategy are out of sync, the consequences tend to follow a familiar pattern:

• Slower value creation due to delays in hiring or onboarding key executives.
• Strategy drift when management and the board interpret priorities differently.
• Cultural instability and turnover among high performers.
• Poor integration during buy‑and‑build activity.
• Missed opportunities for margin improvement or operational upgrades.
• Reduced exit valuations due to weak leadership benches.

Time lost early in the hold period is difficult to recover.

‍

The first 100 days: the launchpad for value creation

Portfolio companies tend to be most open to change right after acquisition. It’s the point where you can reset how the business operates day-to-day, improve reporting habits, and refocus commercial priorities.

That means being specific, not broad job descriptions, but clear expectations based on the results the role must deliver:

• What EBITDA improvements are required?
• Which operational capabilities must be built?
• What must the first year deliver?

At KS Search Partners role definition begins with investment outcomes rather than responsibilities. This ensures leadership alignment before the search starts.

‍

The new executive search mandate in private equity

Search in private equity is no longer about filling roles. It is about ensuring leadership can deliver the strategy investors have underwritten.

High‑performing firms expect their search partners to provide:

• Leadership due diligence support.
• Outcome‑based role design.
• Guidance on equity, expectations, and pace.
• Access to proven operators with portfolio experience.
• Fast, high‑certainty shortlists.

PE environments need advisors who have real experience and can work at the speed the deal requires. When searches rely heavily on junior teams or drag on for months, it slows value creation and frustrates everyone involved.

KS Search Partners was built with this in mind. You work directly with experienced partners, shortlists arrive quickly, and every candidate we put forward has been tested in the pace and pressure of portfolio leadership.

‍

What a modern PE talent strategy looks like

The firms outperforming their peers are applying structured leadership frameworks that include:

• Scorecards are tied directly to the investment thesis.
• Role definitions built around measurable outcomes.
• Organisational design reviews before and after close.
• Pipelines of CFO/COO talent curated in advance.
• Compressed hiring sprints during the first 100 days.
• Succession planning for key functions.
• Clear reporting lines and decision rights.

This turns talent from something you deal with when needed into a deliberate advantage that supports the whole investment plan.

‍

Choosing the right search partner for the Portfolio world

Not all search firms are suited to private equity. The right partner must:

• Deliver at pace without lowering standards.
• Understand the scrutiny and tempo of portfolio environments.
• Provide advisory support on equity, expectations, and role design.
• Communicate discreetly with senior candidates.
• Bring credibility with experienced operators.

Clients often tell us they do not want headhunters. They want advisors who understand investment dynamics and can secure leaders capable of delivering the plan.

‍

Capital alone won’t deliver the plan. The people leading the business do.

Talent sits at the heart of value creation, firms that build leadership planning into their investment thesis, get alignment early, and treat talent as a genuine strategic lever see the difference. They manage risk more effectively, gain momentum sooner, and reach exit with a stronger story.

At KS Search Partners, we believe this is where value is created. Strong leadership builds clarity, pace, and resilience, and investing in it early gives a business a better chance of delivering the outcome investors expect.

Get in touch

If you’d like to discuss how stronger leadership can support your portfolio strategy, you can reach the KS Search Partners team at info@kssearchpartners.com or call us on 317-576-3713. 

‍

This article incorporates insights referenced from the Hunt Scanlon report on private equity talent strategy.